06/22/2026
, June 22, 1776, David Mathews, the last colonial mayor of New York City, was arrested for “being engaged in a Conspiracy against the Authority of the Congress and the Liberties of America.”
Troops led by Colonel James Mitchell Varnum arrived at Mathews’ Flatbush estate at 1:00 a.m. on June 22nd to arrest him and search the house for evidence.
The “Conspiracy” mentioned in the warrant was actually a plot to assassinate George Washington. Although his culpability is not certain, Mathews was sent from his estate in Flatbush to Litchfield, Connecticut, where he was kept in prison. He wrote from prison that Patriot officials "know it [the charge of conspiracy] is false as hell is false."
Later paroled, he and several other Loyalists managed to escape, and Mathews returned to British-held Manhattan in November of 1776.
Patriot Major Seymour actually placed a runaway ad in the “Connecticut Journal,” offering a $50 reward for Mathews who was “charged with high crimes against the American States,” and who had “basely and perfidiously deserted.” The ad also describes him as “well made, about 6 feet high, short brown hair, about 39 years old, and has a very plausible way of deceiving people.”
Mathews continued as official mayor in New York, albeit with few responsibilities, given the British Army’s takeover of the city. His 25,000 acre estate on Long Island and two Manhattan homes were included in the 1779 New York Act of Attainder, which banished him from the state. He evacuated with the British to Nova Scotia in November of 1783.
He was a divisive figure in New York and later Canadian politics. New York Loyalist William Smith described him as “profligate, abandoned, and dissipated, indigent, extravagant, and voluptuous as himself.” Another Loyalist, Peter Dubois, accused him of corruption, including taking a cut of military raids on the countryside and even lying about supporting the Poor House.
In Canada, he moved to Cape Breton and became its attorney general and a member of the Executive Council. He quickly made enemies and tried to get the colony’s governor removed. Ultimately successful, he was later appointed administrator of the colony, until he was in turn removed and investigated in 1789. The investigation was inconclusive, and Mathews died in 1800 at the age of 61.
Image: Detail of map of Brooklyn depicting Flatbush, 1770. Library of Congress.