08/23/2026
12 perfect innings. 36 up, 36 down. AND Harvey Haddix lost the game.
That story has been sitting in the back of my head for years, but somebody suggested Haddix to me a couple weeks ago and suddenly I started seeing it differently.
Not just as a baseball story, but as a story about what happens to stories after they happen. I started thinking about my old grade-school yearbooks. The book itself never changed, but my copy sure did. Bullies got horns and mustaches if they didn't get scribbled out all together. Girls I liked got hearts around their pictures. Eventually the printed story and my version of it became the same object.
That’s where this cover idea came from. Haddix was perfect for 12 innings on May 26, 1959. In the 13th, a runner reached on an error, Joe Adcock later got the hit, and Milwaukee won 1–0. Then, more than 30 years later, baseball changed the official definition of a no-hitter and Haddix’s game was removed from the list. The game didn’t change. The 36 straight outs didn’t change. The story around them did.
So I imagined this as an old romance comic somebody had owned since '59 ... and at some point, knowing how it all turned out, grabbed a pen and scribbled across the cover.
Harvey’s response to the record-book change years later:
“It’s O.K. I know what I did.”
Yeah. Exactly.
Pop Fly #255 — Harvey Haddix: ̶P̶E̶R̶F̶E̶C̶T̶
Available now for one week. Grab yours before you can't.