06/01/2026
I hope that when judges come to California to judge our breed, the Xoloitzcuintle, they truly evaluate the dogs and not the handlers.
I am considering stepping away from conformation shows, as I no longer feel comfortable continuing to invest time and money without a sense of fair and impartial evaluation.
I have been competing as an owner-handler for two years and have shown four different dogs, including a World Champion bitch. However, it often seems that the breed is awarded to the same type of exhibitor. During this time, I have received very positive feedback about my handling from professional handlers, so I am confident that presentation is not the issue.
Over time, I have come to the conclusion that some judges seem to know certain handlers better than the breed they are judging. At times, it gives the impression that the handler is being evaluated more than the dog, which leaves truly outstanding dogs out of the top placements in the ring. This directly affects those of us who invest time, money, and effort into presenting quality dogs.
It is also disheartening to see how dogs coming from Europe, Mexico, and other countries have their competitive progress limited when they arrive in Southern California, often losing to other dogs that appear to benefit more from who is handling them rather than their actual merit.
I was considering attending the AKC show in Mexico this November, but after reviewing the judge panel and seeing who would be judging the breed on the first day, I decided not to spend my money on something I did not feel confident about. It is widely known that the first decision can influence the rest of the event.
I am no longer frustrated; rather, I find it somewhat surprising to observe the apparent reluctance of some judges to award the breed to an outstanding dog coming from the classes, simply because it does not yet hold the Champion title.
Titles should be the result of an objective and correct evaluation of the dog, not the factor that determines whether it is worthy of winning.