10/10/2022
Okay, this one is over 300 words. I tried to make it shorter, but it didn't work out. I think they are good words. :)
Now where was I? Oh yes, to method or not to method. Let’s consider that now that we have a little background. So the supposed “method”—Remember, Stanislavski said he never intend to start one—developed in an effort to make acting more natural, less staged and more ‘real.’ And that’s the first reason I don’t care much for it. It doesn’t accomplish that.
It doesn’t accomplish that because by placing the importance on the actor instead of on the character, it invites excess, tortured, self-aware and in a sense arrogant work by actors who are focused in making the character into their own idea of what they want to make him or her instead of on the character him or herself, as developed by the playwright’s of screenwriter’s description and direction along with such minor bits of evidence as the character’s own dialogue, actions, reactions to other characters, and theirs to him/her.
People within the ‘method’ school like to refer to “the actor’s truth,’ a clear indication that the actor comes before the character, who shall be bent to the actor’s will, instead of the other way around.
The other reason I don’t care for method acting is simpler. It’s unnecessary. It might have been necessary back in 1878 or 1910, but in today’s theatre, every good director and actor already does exactly what Constantin Stanislavski sought. They analyze the script, strive to understand what it tells them about the character, and through study and rehearsal, realize believably the characters presence, actions and reactions. Instead of an “actor’s truth,” they intelligently find the character’s truth.
I would like to recommend the best book about acting I have ever read. The title is ACTING WITHOUT AGONY. The author is Don Richardson, who directed over 800 prime time television episodes, three Broadway plays; whose work won Emmys and Peabody Awards. The bad news is that it is no longer in print, and if you are able to find a copy, it will be costly. If you are truly dedicated to becoming an excellent actor, it will be cheap at the price.