Bizarre Handcrafted Ice Cream

Directions Website

Bizarre Handcrafted Ice Cream ORDER NOW ⬇️⬇️⬇️
https://bizarreicecream.square.site


OR FIND US AT:
New Albany Sugar Shoppe
56 Pearl St
New Albany, IN 47150

Limited drops!

See our page to see updated and current flavors!

09/02/2026

You scream
I scream
We all scream
For ICE CREAM!

🚨‼️WARNING 🚨‼️THIS POST MAY TRIGGER YOUR ICE CREAM CRAVINGPROCEED WITH CAUTION!
09/01/2026

🚨‼️WARNING 🚨‼️

THIS POST MAY TRIGGER YOUR ICE CREAM CRAVING

PROCEED WITH CAUTION!

08/31/2026

🚨 VERY IMPORTANT QUESTION! 🚨

What’s the BEST way to eat an ice cream sandwich?

A- Start with the cookie 🍪
B-Go straight for the ice cream 🍨
C- Eat the edges first 😏
D-Take a giant bite and don’t overthink it 😂

Drop your answer below! 👇

🍦Sweet Sunday calls for something bizarre!🍦Enjoy your Sunday with a sweet handcrafted ice cream sandwich!
08/30/2026

🍦Sweet Sunday calls for something bizarre!🍦

Enjoy your Sunday with a sweet handcrafted ice cream sandwich!

Our Banana pudding ice cream sandwich is creamy delicious banana pudding ice cream with all buttery goodness of ‘Nilla w...
08/30/2026

Our Banana pudding ice cream sandwich is creamy delicious banana pudding ice cream with all buttery goodness of ‘Nilla wafers. Then it’s sandwiched between two chessman dupe cookies

Topped with crushed Nilla wafers and Carmel.

Don’t wait until the next party or get together, Get your banana pudding fix now!

08/28/2026

First bulk order (dozen+) going out today!! Thanks for y’all’s support 🍦❤️

Sweet.Peachy.Buttery.Cinnamon-y.Peach Cobbler Oatmeal Cookie Sandwich Should this be a staple flavor?
08/27/2026

Sweet.
Peachy.
Buttery.
Cinnamon-y.

Peach Cobbler Oatmeal Cookie Sandwich

Should this be a staple flavor?

Get Wacky on a Wednesday by enjoying our Bramble Berry Sugar Cookie Sandwich!Our homemade brambleberry ice cream include...
08/26/2026

Get Wacky on a Wednesday by enjoying our Bramble Berry Sugar Cookie Sandwich!

Our homemade brambleberry ice cream includes a mixture of delicious berries, creamy milk, and some sugar!

The handmade sugar cookie stands up to the amazing ice cream by being subtly sweet but packs a punch!

The sandwich is topped with a birthday cake inspired drizzle of white chocolate, white chocolate chips, and funfetti sprinkles!

Try it today on our website or New Albany Sugar Shoppe

08/25/2026

Finish this sentence.. “Ice cream is better with _____”

08/24/2026

Menu Monday! Our staple sandwich flavors are:
🍪 Chocolate Haznut
🍦Banana Pudding
🍪 Brambleberry Sugar

Address

56 Pearl Street
New Albany, IN
47150

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bizarre Handcrafted Ice Cream posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category