In All Seriousness

04/28/2026

The cast is getting more excited for the season and we're ready to explode! Don't miss out!

🔎🚂 Murder Mystery Dinner Train tickets are disappearing fast!

Our June and July dates are selling quickly, and May is already fully booked. June has just 43 tickets remaining, and July has only 27 left!

If you’ve been thinking about joining us for an evening of mystery, dining, and vintage rail travel through Oil Creek Valley, now is the time to reserve your seats.

🕵️‍♂️ Great food
🚂 Scenic train ride
🔍 Interactive whodunit fun

Don’t wait until your preferred date is gone—order soon!

🎟 Tickets: Call 814-676-1733
📌More info: https://octrr.org/special-events-tours/murder-mystery-dinners/

04/27/2026

Watch out the Stromboli family is out on the loose again. Though mama has passed on Mama's will is still in the air. Come see the chaos the comedy, and if I know the strombolis, the murder. Mystery laughs and great food.. not to mention a great train ride! We'll see you all there!

🚨THIS WEEKEND 🚨
is our 1st Murder Mystery of the year🕵🏻‍♂️🫆 it’s going to be a very fun evening ⤵️
Ticket Price: $65.00

🎤 Mama Mia Mayhem “Blood Relatives”
Presented by In All Seriousness Comedy Club
In All Seriousness
🗓️Saturday, May 2nd, 2026

THEME: Join your favorite big fat Italian clan, the Stromboli Family, as they gather for a memorial service to bid farewell to their beloved matriarch Mama Filomena, who has finally taken off to that big pizza parlor in the sky (this time by natural causes...) Their usual raucous rivalry to inherit the family business is finally at an end--- or is it?
Mystery guests and secrets from the past abound as the family
that “preys” together tries to stay together… until one of those loaded cannoli’s hits its mark! Once again murder shows its ugly
face in the Stromboli family portrait! Match your wits against the witless and try to solve tonight’s whacking---err, murder, before the spaghetti sauce hits the fan again!

Are you the hero? Or the next victim? 🕵️‍♂️ Put on your detective hat and dive into a night of totally tubular twists and turns!

🍽️ 5-Hour Catered Experience Includes:
📍 4:30 PM – Check-In / 5:00 PM – Dinner
Hosted by Gowanda Loyal Order Of Moose 1382 – 201 Aldrich Street, Gowanda, NY (Menu coming soon!)

🚂 6:30 PM – Board the New York & Lake Erie Railroad
2-hour roundtrip Murder Mystery Train Ride
50 Commercial Street, Gowanda, NY

🍰 8:45 PM – Return for Dessert back at the Gowanda Loyal Order Of Moose 1382

⚠️ Recommended for Ages 16+

☎️ Book your tickets now at www.nylerailroad.com or call (716)532-5242

04/16/2026

Get out of the rain and in on the fun! Come join us for an evening of laughter great food and a little murder! You deserve a great night out.. call today!

Join us for a thrilling Murder Mystery Dinner Show at Cork n Screw Wines – great food, wine, and suspense!

03/27/2026

Rodger L Montgomery 💙💙
50 Miles to Empty ❤️❤️

03/11/2026

KICKING OFF OUR 2026 SEASON AND WOULD LOVE TO SEE YOU AT ONE OF OUR SHOWS!!!

VENUE CONTACT INFO
OIL CREEK/TITUSVILLE RR (814) 676-1733
MADELINES RESTERAUNT & EVENTS (814) 402-1075
AMERICAN LEGION JAMESTOWN (716) 483-0777
NEW YORK LAKE ERIE RR (716) 532-5242
CORK AND SCREW WINES (814) 657-9664
AMERICAN LEGION GIRARD (814) 774-3326
BEAR RUN CAMPGROUND (724) 368-3564
VACATIONLANDS CAMPGROUND (724) 253-4645

Medvale High School Mayhem
“Class of ’85 40 th Reunion!”
Available May 2025 thru May 2026

You’re attending the 40-year class reunion for the Medvale High
School class of ’85, (Go Fighting Sea Cucumbers!) Some of your
classmates here tonight haven’t changed much at all since you
graduated, and you begin the evening reminiscing about the good
old days, getting re-acquainted, and grooving to the totally tubular
hits from the MTv era.
But gag me with a spoon! Someone’s got a secret from 1985 that
could play havoc with their current life, and will totally kill to keep it
from coming out. So find out if you’re a totally awesome detective
or a totally bogus one, and test your wits against the finest minds
to come out of Medvale HS back in 1985!
But beware---sometimes when skeletons come out of the closet, it
can wind up being someone you cheated off of in Algebra class!

Mama Mia Mayhem
“Blood Relatives”
Available August 2025 thru September 2026

Join your favorite big fat Italian clan, the Stromboli Family, as they
gather for a memorial service to bid farewell to their beloved
matriarch Mama Filomena, who has finally taken off to that big
pizza parlor in the sky (this time by natural causes...) Their usual
raucous rivalry to inherit the family business is finally at an end---
or is it?

Mystery guests and secrets from the past abound as the family
that “preys” together tries to stay together… until one of those
loaded cannoli’s hits its mark! Once again murder shows its ugly
face in the Stromboli family portrait!
Match your wits against the witless and try to solve tonight’s
whacking---err, murder, before the spaghetti sauce hits the fan---
again!

Medium Mayhem
“Murder in the Sixth Sense”
Available May 2026 thru May 2027

You and your group are attending Krystal Powers’ Spiritual Expo, a
psychic fair where many of the greatest local psychics are
showcasing their “miraculous” mystical talents in an effort to win this year’s “Seer of the Year” award. It’s a funny and light-hearted romp through the world of the paranormal until one of them foretells of murder--- to be committed this very evening by one of them!

See if you can tell the “psychic” from the just plain “psycho” as the
dark prophesy unfolds and a homicide does take place in front of all.

We predict you’ll thoroughly enjoy this evening of mystic mystery,
phenomenal phenomena and side-splitting sideshows!

Mercury Lanes
“The Fatal Strike!”
Available September 2026 thru May 2028

It’s the Mercury Lanes Mixed League Bowling Banquet, a time to
recognize the winners, losers and just plain pin-heads of the nuttiest bowling alley in town. All team rivalries are put aside on this one night to celebrate their achievements together---or are they?

When the awards ceremony gets underway the good-natured ribbing and toasting leads to fibbing and roasting and that leads to just plain murder--- with no bowling puns “spared”!

Grab your team shirts and funny shoes and join the league in trying to frame who is going to land the Fatal Strike!

02/05/2026

It's going to be a killer evening with some killer food!

https://www.clover.com/online-ordering/DavenportCidery

01/13/2026

IMPROV CLASSES ARE BACK!!

01/13/2026

12/24/2025

A Very Merry Christmas to all! From all of us to all of you. Can't wait to make more laughter and memories!

10/26/2025

It's murder in a murder mystery in a murder mystery. And it's a great place for food while you try to figure it out! You deserve this great evening out!

Mark your calendars! Our 1st Murder Mystery Dinner of the season is coming up in two weeks. Doors open at 5pm. Show starts promptly at 6pm. Ticket includes the show, complimentary cocktail, appetizer, salad, entree, and dessert.

RESERVATIONLY ONLY. Call and book your table today! 814.796.2767