Penny and Pearl Productions

04/30/2026

Reviews are streaming in for "Mystic Murder: The Hotel" - It's a hit!!!!!

Get your tickets for the show tonight, still available online or at the door (cash only).

And don't forget, after the show you can meet with Madame Luce herself for an explanation of your chosen tarot card!!!!!

04/29/2026

Opening Tonight!!!!!!

Online tickets can be still be purchased up until 5pm.

And don't forget, Tickets are Available at the Door!!!!!!!!!!!

We can't wait to see your Spirit... I mean... YOU at the show 😉

04/24/2026

Get ready for a spellbinding tale full of suspense, lies, mystery, secrets, betrayal, and of course, DEATH!!!

Join us at 32WestEighth in the Masonic Temple Lodge Room for this SPECIAL TWO DAY EVENT

Purchase tickets online at https://tickets.eriereader.com/events/mystic-murder-the-hotel
*If you get a notice that says "one slot available," click on it and it will take you to the show for that day (we aren't sure why it's set up this way but don't worry, we'll let you know if we're sold out!)

Huge thanks to Cauldron & Thorne for the use of their Vault (make an appt to enter this sacred space) and Digg It Dave for taking the photos of our incredible cast.

04/20/2026

"My blood is on your hands" - Madame Luce (Kerry Lee)

The beautiful and mysterious Madame Luce is here to discover secrets and lies... no one is safe...

Join us at "Mystic Murder: The Hotel" at the Masonic Temple to find out just what she knows... and what she could never have prepared for...

Tickets on Sale at https://tickets.eriereader.com/.../mystic-murder-the-hotel Only 2 available dates, Wednesday, April 29th and Thursday, April 30th!!!!!

Visit 32WestEighth for venue details for the Masonic Temple

Huge thank you to Cauldron & Thorne for providing the PERFECT spot for our photos (check their place out!!)

Credit to our amazing photographer Digg It Dave who always manages to capture just the right looks.

Get your tickets NOW!!!!! All online ticket sales come with a surprise souvenir bag ✨🔮✨

04/17/2026

"I'll never let you down... no matter what" - Mr. Maxwell Benchley (Dee Edward)

Wow, what a sweet guy! Or is he a snake in the grass? Hmmmm...

Join us at "Mystic Murder: The Hotel" at the Masonic Temple to find out!!!

Tickets on Sale at https://tickets.eriereader.com/.../mystic-murder-the-hotel Only 2 available dates, Wednesday, April 29th and Thursday, April 30th!!!!!

Visit 32WestEighth for venue details for the Masonic Temple

Huge thank you to Cauldron & Thorne for providing the PERFECT spot for our photos (check their place out!!)

Credit to our amazing photographer Digg It Dave who always manages to capture just the right looks.

Get your tickets NOW!!!!! All online ticket sales come with a surprise souvenir bag ✨🔮✨

04/15/2026

"Your card is Death" - Ms. Solara (Lara Schaaf)

Yikes! That card can only mean one thing... right? Maybe it's not what you think...
Join us at "Mystic Murder: The Hotel" at the Masonic Temple to find out!!!

Tickets on Sale at https://tickets.eriereader.com/.../mystic-murder-the-hotel Only 2 available dates, Wednesday, April 29th and Thursday, April 30th!!!!!

Visit 32WestEighth for venue details for the Masonic Temple

Huge thank you to Cauldron & Thorne for providing the PERFECT spot for our photos (check their place out!!)

Credit to our amazing photographer Digg It Dave who always manages to capture just the right looks.

Get your tickets NOW!!!!! All online ticket sales come with a surprise souvenir bag ✨🔮✨

04/13/2026

"But I didn't know... how could I have known???" - Ben (Mike DeCorte)

Want to know his deepest regret? Join us at "Mystic Murder: The Hotel" at the Masonic Temple to find out!!!

Tickets on Sale at https://tickets.eriereader.com/events/mystic-murder-the-hotel Only 2 available dates, Wednesday, April 29th and Thursday, April 30th!!!!!

Visit 32WestEighth for venue details for the Masonic Temple

Huge thank you to Cauldron & Thorne for providing the PERFECT spot for our photos (check their place out!!)

Credit to our amazing photographer Dave Schroeder who always manages to capture just the right looks.

Get your tickets NOW!!!!! All online ticket sales come with a surprise souvenir bag ✨🔮✨

04/04/2026

Poster created by Katie Marie ❤️

04/03/2026

Tickets are now LIVE for the first show in our new "Mystic Murder" series.

Don't wait on this one!!

Join Penny & Pearl Productions in The Masonic Temple Lodge Room for a frightening evening full of surprises in "Mystic Murder: The Hotel," written and directed by Adele Crotty. Bar services provided by Cali's West Catering will be available beginning at 5:30pm and continuing through intermission. Do...

12/20/2025

Penny & Pearl is doing a "Surprise" Murder Mystery Event this evening and we are so EXCITED!!!

As usual, this troupe has been tasked with doing something wildly creative, which has never been done before (it's kind of our brand ;) ), and traveling over an hour away to do it. This is definitely our biggest challenge yet, but we are up to the task and raring to go✨️🎄✨️

Stay tuned for more details on how YOU can book Penny & Pearl for you next event!!!!!

08/26/2025

There is only ONE ticket left for the ENTIRE RUN of "Murder on the Rocks"... how is this even possible!?!?!?

Snag the last ticket and join us on Wednesday, August 26th for the show EVERYONE is talking about!!!

Step back in time at Erie's favorite Speakeasy "Room 33" for an all new Murder Mystery Dinner Production, "Murder on the Rocks". Presented by Penny & Pearl Productions and Room 33. Written and Directed by Adele Crotty. Featuring; Chad Santos, Tony Lewandowski, Katie States, Lisa Simonian, &....