08/09/2022
This article of mine first appeared in Postcard History magazine.
So far, I have been unable to trace the artist. If anyone knows, please contact me!
DON'T MONKEY WITH THAT TELEPHONE!
Some of the most entertaining postcards in my collection are those showing animals getting into human predicaments. This postcard (copyright 1906), captioned “Don’t Monkey,” features a painting of three monkeys apeing human behaviors as they play with a telephone. The painting is by an unknown artist in the manner of British artist Sir Edwin Landseer (1802-1873). On the simplest level, it’s an early twentieth-century equivalent of our silly pet videos on YouTube. On a deeper level, it’s a parody of society’s reaction to early telephones-- with a moral message attached.
Collectors often classify this postcard as an anthropomorphic card since it shows animals acting like people. Another term for it is “singerie”- the French term for “monkey trick.” Singeries first became popular in Dutch art during the sixteenth century. The most common singeries show monkeys dressed in human clothes mimicking human behavior- as if they desperately want to become human. The picture reproduced on this postcard, which was probably painted during the Victorian era, continues the tradition of singeries.
The Victorians enjoyed monkeys' attempts to imitate humans. It was believed that monkeys couldn't think rationally or comprehend their own actions. Therefore, primates were seen as lesser beings. Although they’re our relatives, they’re still not quite human! So, it was socially acceptable to use monkeys to make fun of human behavior in singers. At their cruelest, singeries satirized our obsession with the latest trends-- like the telephone.
The singerie on this postcard can also be classified as a narrative painting because it tells a story. It's up to you to figure out what's going on! The monkey on the right is mimicking a human speaking into the telephone. He’s dropped a pair of eyeglasses and a feathered cap. Has the ringing telephone interrupted his attempt to dress in human clothes? The monkey on the left holds the receiver, listening but is unsure what to do. He’s sitting on a book. Is this monkey chewing on its pages in frustration after a failed attempt to read? The monkey in the center unwittingly plays saboteur, nibbling on the phone cord. He doesn’t understand that his actions are dangerous and may result in electric shock. Today, the monkeys’ antics make us laugh. But in 1906, this image was meant to poke fun at people’s awkward attempts to use early telephones- and their reactions to the new technology.
For many years after its invention in 1876 by Alexander Graham Bell, the telephone was seen as a dangerous tool used only by the foolhardy. This explains the postcard’s title “Don’t Monkey.” People who rushed out to buy the first telephones were seen as foolish. How useful is a telephone when the only other person you know who has one is the operator?
The caption of the postcard also hints at fears that kept many people from monkeying around with the phone long after it first appeared. Don’t monkey with that gadget or you might get spied on through the party line! Don’t monkey around with that gizmo; listening to voices on it might make you sick or mentally ill! Perhaps most of all, people feared lightning strikes or electric shock while talking on the phone. Early phone company advertisements went to great lengths to subtly reassure the public, while also promoting the magical convenience of this new apparatus. They conveyed the message that the telephone wasn’t a silly fad; it was here to stay.
The telephone isn’t the only object on this postcard that’s significant. Take a closer look and you’ll see an animal skull in the
background. In still-life paintings, this type of symbolic motif is called a “memento mori”. Memento mori commonly appear in a genre of still life art known as “Vanitas” paintings. Objects such as skulls, flowers, pocket watches, burnt-out candles, upended hourglasses, or empty oil lamps symbolize the fleeting nature of time. These details remind us of our mortality. The skull warns us “life is short, so act wisely”. (Misuse this newfangled contraption called a telephone and you might end up dead!)
The painting reproduced on this postcard is a social satire. At the deepest level, it asks us to look at ourselves. If we blindly go out and buy the latest iPhone or other technological gadgets as soon as they appear, have we regressed to the monkeys’ cognitive level? Is there really such a big difference between us and the three monkeys shown here?
Perhaps the monkeys are also warning us that going outside proper social norms can be dangerous. If the “lower orders” attempt to ape their betters, the result can be disastrous. This was something that was of great concern to the Victorians. Trying to be something you’re not can get you into trouble, so don’t meddle with things you don’t understand. Want to get a newfangled technological gadget to monkey around with? Be careful what you wish for!
Copyright 2021 Anne Ross