05/10/2025
Donald Trump never meant to keep his promises. His voters are starting to notice, Yair Rosenberg writes. https://theatln.tc/vqeoqFvT
On Sunday, Trump told Americans that their children should make do with less. “They don’t need to have 30 dolls; they can have three,” the president said on “Meet the Press.” The comments contradicted campaign commitments: Throughout his 2024 run, the president promised Americans a return to the prosperity of his pre-COVID first term, while also promising to impose steep tariffs on consumer goods.
“These two pledges could not be reconciled, and once elected, Trump was forced to choose between them,” Rosenberg writes. The results have disillusioned many of those who voted for him, and his approval on the economy has plunged.
It’s not just the economy. “On issue after issue, whether domestic policy or foreign affairs, the president made incompatible assurances to rival camps on the campaign trail—to business bigwigs and working-class factory hands, anti-war isolationists and anti-Iran hawks,” Rosenberg continues. “Now that Trump is in office, the bill for these guarantees is coming due, and he is making decisions that will inevitably alienate one of his constituencies. Some of the supporters who are not getting what they were promised are beginning to feel ripped off, putting the coalition that propelled Trump to his narrow popular-vote victory in jeopardy.”
“These disappointments were entirely predictable,” Rosenberg writes. “Because Trump lacks many core convictions, voters from entirely opposite backgrounds convinced themselves that he would act in their interest as president—and he was happy to indulge their fantasies in exchange for their support by teasing tantalizing prizes to people across divides. But Trump’s transactionalism has limits, because even presidents who have few beliefs still need to act, and those actions have consequences for the world and for the politician’s coalition.”
📸: Jim Watson / AFP / Getty