First Company Theatre

First Company Theatre First Company Theatre is based in Colorado Springs Recent shows include 'She Loves Me", "Peter and the Star Catchers" and "Secret Garden: The Musical".

First Company is a theatre company based in First United Methodist Church that has been presenting high quality theatrical and musical performances for over 25 years.

FCT Presents: I Remember MamaFebruary 27 - March 8, 2026Details and Ticketing:https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-...
03/05/2026

FCT Presents: I Remember Mama
February 27 - March 8, 2026

Details and Ticketing:
https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4

Review in OnStageColorado
By Judith Sears | March 4, 2026
Read the review here: https://onstagecolorado.com/first-company-takes-a-sentimental-journey-in-i-remember-mama/

Upcoming Auditions

The Philadelphia Story: March 16-17, 2026
Sign-Up: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSebMUisceQtmMZavweZcI89aFOMIse9lab5RjuCwckKLpPgdw/viewform?pli=1

Fiddler on the Roof: June 22-24, 2026

02/27/2026

First Company Theatre Presents: ✨ I Remember Mama ✨
February 27 – March 8, 2026
🎉 Opens Tonight! 🎉

Step into the warmth, humor, and heart of an immigrant family chasing the American dream. I Remember Mama tells the story of the Hansons — a Norwegian family living in early 20th-century San Francisco — as seen through the loving memories of daughter Katrin. Through life’s everyday joys and challenges, Mama’s quiet strength, faith, and unwavering love hold the family together.
You’ll laugh, you’ll tear up, and before you know it, you’ll feel like part of the family. ❤️
Join us and experience a story that celebrates home, hope, and the people who shape us. We can’t wait to welcome you into the Hanson household!
🎟️ Details & Tickets:
https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4?fbclid=IwY2xjawQO469leHRuA2FlbQIxMABicmlkETFEbXI4QmlGbG51RnNnVElEc3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHhT4Le_We0T5roswqnKGlQCYPzx7E3MLPDSJ9qcVvI8SraN8szRi_3IRb2VQ_aem_ly4-OsK56eWBnMAVUQdUQQ

FCT Presents: I Remember MamaFebruary 27 - March 8, 20261 Week to Opening Night!Details and Ticketing:https://www.onthes...
02/19/2026

FCT Presents: I Remember Mama
February 27 - March 8, 2026
1 Week to Opening Night!

Details and Ticketing:
https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4

The story recounts the everyday life and economic struggles of a Norwegian immigrant family in San Francisco in the early 20th century.

Mark Your Calendars - Audition Dates

The Philadelphia Story: March 16-17, 2026
Signups: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSebMUisceQtmMZavweZcI89aFOMIse9lab5RjuCwckKLpPgdw/viewform?pli=1

Fiddler on the Roof: June 22-24, 2026

FCT Presents: I Remember MamaFebruary 27 - March 8, 2026Details and Ticketing:https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-...
02/12/2026

FCT Presents: I Remember Mama
February 27 - March 8, 2026

Details and Ticketing:
https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4

The Show's Taking Shape!
The story recounts the everyday life and economic struggles of a Norwegian immigrant family in San Francisco in the early 20th century.

Mark Your Calendars - Audition Dates
The Philadelphia Story: March 16-17, 2026
Fiddler on the Roof: June 22-24, 2026

FCT Presents: I Remember MamaFebruary 27 - March 8, 2026Details and Ticketing: https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first...
02/04/2026

FCT Presents: I Remember Mama
February 27 - March 8, 2026

Details and Ticketing: https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4

Meet the Cast (Pt. 2)

Michaela Wojick (Christine)
Howdy! Michaela is a 2025 graduate of UCCS with a bachelor's in Performing Arts. She loves everything in theatre; from singing,acting and clowning to scenic design and dramaturgy. She is excited to return to her love of performance and be on stage with this lovely cast. Enjoy the show!

Anna Williams (Aunt Jenny)
Anna is from Baltimore, Maryland. She moved to Colorado Springs in 2018 and has been almost non-stop doing shows within the community. She studied Film / TV / Theatrical acting in New York City. You may have seen her in; “Guys and Dolls” - Sunrise Players. “Our Shorts are Showing” - Craft Productions. “The Mousetrap” - First Company. She's super excited to hit the stage again at First Company as Aunt Jenny. *try not to hate her too much*

Kevin Townsend (Uncle Chris)
After a several-week run as a successful candy entrepreneur, Kevin left northern Europe for the sunny West Coast of America, where he flips distressed properties for profit! He also grows and sells citrus fruit. When you visit Ukiah, try catching his spontaneous karaoke act in the local Norwegian tavern!

Nahum Young (Mr. Thorkelson)
Nahum has been performing in theatre since he was 12 and has appeared in four productions with First Company, most notably as Charlie Dalrymple in Brigadoon. He is currently a student at Pikes Peak State College and would like to thank his mom and dad for enduring countless hours of practice.

John Cherry (Dr. Johnson)
John is thrilled to portray Dr. Johnson in this production. He has appeared in numerous plays and musicals throughout his career, bringing diverse characters to life on stage. John is grateful for the opportunity to share this story with audiences and thanks his family and friends for their continued support.

Caitlin Hull (Arne)
Excited to be in this show and grateful for the opportunity to act alongside her younger sister Christiana, acting has always been important to Caitlin. "I regard the theatre as the greatest of all art forms, the most immediate way in which a human being can share with another the sense of what it is to be a human being." - Oscar Wilde

Christiana Hull (Madeline)
Christiana has been doing theatre since she was nine years old and aspires to be a professional actress someday. Her credits include The Velveteen Rabbit, Peter Pan, and A Christmas with Scrooge. Christiana is so grateful to be part of I Remember Mama and can’t wait for you to experience the production!

Alora Lee (Dorothy Schiller / Nurse / Jessie)
Alora Lee has done theater since she was seven and greatly loves the theater community.

Sara Day (Florence Moorehead)
Sara Day is making her First Company debut. A lifelong theater kid, Sara particularly loved taking part in After Magritte, Alice in Wonderland, and The Dinner Party. She is an editor and project manager, an avid reader and movie watcher, and a stitcher, and she loves traveling with her family.

FCT Presents: I Remember MamaFebruary 27 - March 8, 2026Details and Ticketing:https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-...
01/28/2026

FCT Presents: I Remember Mama
February 27 - March 8, 2026

Details and Ticketing:
https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4

Meet the Cast (Pt. 1)

Victoria Sullivan (Katrin)
Victoria is a senior at Odyssey ECCO and will be attending CU Boulder as a neuroscience major in the fall. This is her first show with First Company, and she is thrilled to be involved with her local theatre community. Victoria performs live music with a band and as a solo act, and hopes to continue her artistic career in Boulder.

Nora Faircloth (Mama)
Nora is honored to introduce you to Mama today. Favorite previous shows include The Mousetrap (Mrs. Boyle), Lucky Stiff (Rita), and The Wizard of Oz (Wicked Witch). All her love to her people and thank you Jesus that we get to make art in this world!

Josh Wright (Papa)
Josh is excited to be in his fourth production with First Company and in a show as simply beautiful as this. He previously starred in “The Secret Garden”, “Once Upon a Musical”, and “Peter and the Starcatcher”. Not onstage, Josh loves movies, reading, listening to Taylor Swift, and dreaming of a brighter, kinder world. Jeremiah 29:11

Ellie Faircloth (Dagmar)
This is Ellie’s first show with First Company. She is very excited to be playing the role of the younger sister, Dagmar. In her free time she likes to play her trumpet, sing, and play with her dog, Huckleberry. She also competes with her high school marching band.

Zack Engleman (Mr. Hyde)
This is Zach's seventh performance with First Company. Recent credits include props coordinator for Cabaret and Romeo and Juliet. Zach was also part of SM for Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill and A Midsummer Night’s Dream with Theatreworks Colorado Springs. Zach is a high school theater teacher working on his Masters degree at UCCS.

Zack Van Valkenburg (Nels)
Zach is an Intelligence Officer in the United States Space Force. Zach was a member of the Bluebard’s Theatre Troupe at the United States Air Force Academy and a founding member of the Masqueraders Improv Club at the United States Naval Academy. Just finishing Guys and Dolls with Sunrise, he is excited for his first show with First Company.

Nora Wingert (Aunt Trina)
Eleanor is excited to return to First Company’s stage for I Remember Mama, a story she first shared with her own Mother, who sparked Eleanor’s journey after catching a subtle hint when Eleanor pointed to a Fred and Ginger movie. May this story inspire your own dear memories of Mama.

Debbie Louis (Aunt Sigrid)
Debbie has been part of First Company since she was ten. She has had bit parts and chorus roles in many shows. Her latest role was Vera in First Baptist of Ivy Gap. Debbie teaches first grade, sings in the Chancel Choir, and plays handbells here at First Church.

FCT Presents: I Remember MamaFebruary 27 - March 8, 2026Details and Ticketing:https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-...
01/24/2026

FCT Presents: I Remember Mama
February 27 - March 8, 2026
Details and Ticketing:
https://www.onthestage.tickets/show/first-united-methodist-church/696a948ba201b7335f7ba3a4

Meet the Crew

Director
Marty Fennewald
Marty Fennewald (Director) and his wife Trudy are one of the five couples that founded First Company Theatre in 1987. Marty has been the Artistic Director for First Company Theatre for 30 years. He has directed over 60 shows and designed and constructed that many sets and more for First Company Theatre and other theatres up and down the front range. He and his wife Trudy officially joined First United Methodist Church in Feb of 1975. They have two incredible daughters, Aubrey Jennifer and Elaina June and nine, eight here, one in heaven, totally awesome grandchildren. Life is good today!

Stage Manager
Danielle Pate
To quote the great Jessica Fletcher, “There are three things you can never have enough of in life: chocolate, friends, and the theatre.” This is Danielle’s sixth show with FC and she’s so proud of I Remember Mama’s cast and team. So, invite your friends, and grab some chocolate from the concessions!

Lighting Designer
Kitty Robbins
Kitty Robbins, a member of Springs Ensemble Theater, has designed lighting for many First Company productions, most recently Brigadoon and The Mousetrap. She has raised two theatre geeks of her own and continues to mentor the next generation at PPSC. Kitty wishes to thank her husband, Dan, for his unwavering support. Although a bona fide introvert, Kitty would enjoy chatting with you about life, theatre, and/or dogs. She hopes you enjoy the show!

Set Designer
Ryan Faircloth
Ryan has enjoyed getting back into theatre for the last three years. He's honored to be trusted with the responsibility to design and build the set for this show. Getting to do theatre with his wife and daughter is a great privilege.

Light Operator
Arthur Rubin

Props Master
Caitline Hull

Props Master
Christiana Hull

Costumer
Kylee Cotterman
Kylee Cotterman (she/her) has over six years of experience in costuming. Her credits include Ugly Lies the Bone (2019) as Assistant Costumes/Makeup, and Circle Mirror Transformation (2023) and Act a Lady (2024) as Head Costume Designer. Kylee strives to bring her designs to life with detail and authenticity while remaining true to her vision.

Assistant Stage Manager
Alex Crozier

Photos / Promotions
Jamie Foster
Jamie Foster (Photos/Promotions) has played in several First Company shows including God’s Favorite and Sister Act and was on the FCT Board 2019-2022. Other roles include The Mayor in Bye Bye Birdie and The Music Man, and Grandpa Potts in Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, He was Music Director for The Wizard of Oz. He’s photographed over 70 shows since 2013.

Address

420 N Nevada Avenue
Colorado Springs, CO
80903

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when First Company Theatre posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Establishment

Send a message to First Company Theatre:

Share