First Avenue Playhouse

09/16/2026

I, SUSPECT, by Eric Hackler. Directed by Tara London.
News anchor Cyrus Telyn has been murdered. Two detectives assigned to the case have a challenge when every one of their suspects claims to be guilty.
Hopefully by the end, they'll have the answer to the big question: Who Didn't Dunnit?

Cast
Vince Fay
Frank Van Syckel
Rebeccah Burnett
Chantal Lentz
Nathalia Dworakowski
Ashley Burroughs
Donna Sanford
Robert Burnett
Chris Poole

Dessert & Play $30
*Students / Seniors $25
*Fri & Sun only
Your admission to the play includes:
Dessert and coffee or tea a half hour before curtain and soda at intermission.
Please call our 24 hour reservations line, leave a message and we will return your call. 732-291-7552
Dinner/dessert/theatre packages are available.

09/05/2026

08/20/2026

Cocktail Hour Confessions directed by Dave McGrath. Jared Kelner’s original thought-provoking dramedy. Aug 14–29 at First Avenue Playhouse, Desert Theatre, Atlantic Highlands, NJ. Evenings Fri & Sat at 7:30 PM. Two Sunday Matinees: August 16 & 23 at 2:30 PM. $30 includes dessert, coffee & soda. Senior and student pricing: $25 on Fridays & Sundays.

Box office: 732-291-7552.

07/11/2026

'Harvey' the comedy classic returns to First Avenue for the month of July 2026.