31/08/2026
There are some honours that feel overdue; then there are omissions that become almost impossible to explain. Pauline Collins should have been made a Dame long before Britain lost her. By the time the beloved actress died in November 2025, aged 85, she had given more than six decades to British theatre, television and film, yet the highest state recognition she received was an OBE in 2001. For an actress of her achievement, longevity and affection in the public imagination, that somehow never felt enough.
Collins had already become a familiar face years before Shirley Valentine. Her wonderfully spirited Sarah Moffat in Upstairs, Downstairs helped turn her into one of television’s most recognisable performers of the 1970s. She later appeared alongside her husband John Alderton in Thomas & Sarah and No, Honestly, while her wider television career stretched from Emergency Ward 10 and Doctor Who to acclaimed productions such as Bleak House.
But it was W***y Russell’s Shirley Valentine that revealed just how extraordinary she was. Collins first conquered the stage in the one-woman play, carrying an entire evening virtually alone and transforming an ordinary Liverpool housewife’s longing for freedom into something funny, painful and deeply universal. She won both the Laurence Olivier Award and the Tony Award for the role.
Then came the 1989 film. Collins won the BAFTA for Best Actress and received an Academy Award nomination, competing at the Oscars alongside some of the most celebrated actresses in world cinema. Shirley was not glamorous or heroic in the conventional sense; she was middle-aged, lonely, witty and searching for the person she had once been. Collins made millions recognise something of themselves in her.
And Shirley Valentine was hardly the end. City of Joy, Paradise Road, Quartet, Albert Nobbs and many other performances demonstrated a range that could move effortlessly between comedy and considerable emotional weight. Colleagues repeatedly remembered not merely her talent but her generosity: an actress capable of commanding attention without appearing to demand it.
That is why the absence of a damehood now feels particularly glaring. Pauline Collins did not need a title to prove her greatness — the Olivier, Tony, BAFTA, Oscar nomination and generations of viewers had already done that. But honours are also supposed to recognise sustained national contribution. If a career as distinguished, enduring and quintessentially British as hers did not merit “Dame Pauline Collins”, it is difficult to imagine what more she was expected to achieve.