16/04/2026
2011 - MUSICAL OF MUSICAL - THE MUSICAL
2012 - MUSICAL OF MUSICAL - THE MUSICAL - THE REPEAT
In 2011 and again in 2012, Downfield Musical Society presented the sharply satirical musical revue Musical of Musicals: The Musical in the Starlight Showroom, delivering a demanding, fast-paced evening of musical theatre parody that both celebrated and gently dismantled five of the most influential composers in modern stage history.
The piece itself is structured as a “meta-musical”: one simple story is retold five times, each in the distinct style of a major Broadway composer. Originally premiering Off-Broadway at the York Theatre in 2003 before returning in an expanded run at Dodger Stages in 2005, the show quickly became a cult favourite in professional theatre circles. Its appeal lies in its precision—each section is not simply an imitation, but a highly informed pastiche of genuine compositional styles, vocal writing, and staging conventions drawn from major Broadway traditions.
For UK context, the material sits in a lineage of revue-style shows that became popular in fringe and studio theatre spaces across Britain in the late 2000s and early 2010s, particularly in amateur and semi-professional societies. Its performance demands—rapid character switching, stylistic vocal control, and tightly timed comedic delivery—meant it was often chosen by companies seeking a “showcase piece” rather than a traditional book musical. While not a large-scale West End commercial title, it aligns closely with the kind of high-skill, small-cast musical revues that regularly appear in London fringe venues and regional professional studio theatres, where ensemble versatility is often prioritised over spectacle.
The first segment, “Corn!”, reimagines the material through the golden-age optimism of Rodgers & Hammerstein. Set in rural Kansas in August heat, it presents the deceptively simple story of Junita (June), a young woman pressured with eviction and marriage ultimatum. Jitter threatens that she must marry him if she cannot pay her rent, while Big Willy—a carnival barker torn between love and personal freedom—complicates the emotional triangle. The character of Mother Abby becomes the moral centre, urging June to “follow her dream”, which leads into an extended dream ballet sequence characteristic of mid-century American musical theatre. The writing deliberately echoes the sweeping lyricism and pastoral innocence of shows such as Oklahoma!, Carousel, and The Sound of Music, culminating in an intentionally neat and optimistic resolution.
The second segment, “A Little Complex”, shifts dramatically into the neurotic, densely structured world of Stephen Sondheim-inspired musical theatre. Set in a New York apartment complex, the narrative becomes darker and more psychologically fragmented. Jitter is reimagined as a disturbed artist-landlord whose obsession with control escalates into a plot to eliminate his tenants. Jeune, Billy, and Abby each embody stylised neuroses—indecision, intellectual paralysis, and alcoholism—mirroring the thematic complexity found in works such as Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street and Company. The music and lyrics parody Sondheim’s trademark internal rhyme schemes and contrapuntal writing, with the narrative deliberately building toward a morally uncomfortable conclusion where the protagonist’s violent impulses are fulfilled.
“Dear Abby” pivots the tone again into the flamboyant warmth of Jerry Herman-style musical theatre. Here, Aunt Abby is recast as a charismatic Manhattan socialite whose generosity and eccentricity resolve the emotional entanglements of those around her. The parody draws on the exuberance of Hello, Dolly! and Mame, emphasising big vocal moments, glamourous costume changes, and ensemble optimism. In this version, even the previously authoritarian landlord figure is transformed through Abby’s influence into a liberated drag persona, reflecting the show’s playful inversion of identity tropes and musical theatre archetypes.
The fourth segment, “Aspects of Junita”, moves into the world of sung-through mega-musical theatre associated with Andrew Lloyd Webber. The structure becomes operatic and continuous, with heightened emotional stakes and a central obsession with fame and transformation. Junita’s desire to become a star, despite limited talent, drives her into the orbit of the mysterious Sir Phantom Jitter. Her relationship with Bill is strained by the fact that communication is symbolically and literally absent, heightening the emotional disconnection. The sequence deliberately evokes the dramatic language of The Phantom of the Opera, Evita, and Cats, culminating in a dramatic chandelier crash that parodies large-scale West End spectacle.
The final segment, “Speakeasy”, transforms the narrative into a Kander and Ebb-inspired cabaret world of cynicism and survival. Set in 1930s Chicago, the tone is deliberately bleak and stylised, drawing on the aesthetic of Chicago and Cabaret. Here, Juny is forced into increasingly desperate choices to pay her rent, while Villy is imprisoned and emotionally unavailable. The emcee figure, Jütter, presides over the action with detached irony, reinforcing the show’s final descent into theatrical cynicism and moral ambiguity.
In keeping with the original professional structure of the piece, the finale brings the cast together for a meta-theatrical closing number parodying “One” from A Chorus Line, reframed here as “Done”, which acknowledges the constructed nature of the entire evening and the repetition of theatrical form itself.
The 2011 production was directed by Graeme Neil Smith, with musical direction by Richard Waghorn and choreography by Christine Low. The company featured Zoe Glenn, Rebecca Waghorn, Ross Glenn, and Thomas Richmond, supported musically by Richard Waghorn on vocals and keyboards. The ensemble format reflected the demands of the material, requiring each performer to shift rapidly between stylistic registers ranging from golden-age musical theatre vocalism to contemporary Sondheim-style character acting and full cabaret performance.
When revived in 2012 as Musical of Musicals – The Musical – The Repeat, the production retained the same creative team and cast, reinforcing the show’s self-referential nature and allowing for refinements in timing, vocal detail, and stylistic precision. The repeat staging also reflected a broader trend within UK amateur and semi-professional theatre of revisiting high-impact revue shows, where repetition often leads to increased technical polish and sharper comedic ex*****on.
Overall, both productions demonstrated a strong understanding of the source material’s professional lineage—from its Off-Broadway origins and subsequent commercial recognition in New York, to its adaptability within UK fringe and society theatre contexts—while showcasing DMS’s capacity to handle vocally and stylistically demanding contemporary musical theatre.
Both programmes are appended