05/10/2023
There's a phrase I've seen pop up several times on social media in the last few years: "Rights are not pie."
It addresses the knee-jerk response some people have whenever another group who is different to them, by their race, gender, sexual orientation or religious belief, has the opportunity to gets rights that move them towards equality.
The idea that trans rights means less rights for woman, legalising gay marriage takes something away from heterosexual marriage, protection or even just acknowledgment of other beliefs takes away the rights of those who believe in Jesus or the Christian God. And of course the idea that recognising and representing First Peoples in any colonised country somehow takes away from those who are part of the 'white majority'.
The fundamental basis for this reaction is fear, but I think it also gets at something a bit darker. Historically the practise of western colonisation has been to take away the rights of indigenous people, stripping them of their land, access to resources, culture, language and tearing families apart. Our prosperity has come at the cost of the First Peoples of Australia and the Torres Strait. We like to tell ourselves that we got here purely through graft and ingenuity, but the reality is we came, conquered and all but obliterated the people who were here before.
I think the reason people think giving Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander people a Voice and representation to parliment will take their own rights away is because that is what we, as a British/European colonial society have done since the start. We are afraid that other people will do to us what we have done to them.
Some people refuse to acknowledge this past and just want to brush it over. Or they are uncomfortable with the idea of addressing the inequality that Indigenous people still face in Australia. That to do so would require such a massive amount of financial reperations the whole country would be financially crippled.
I hope in 2023 we can be more evolved than that.
Giving other people rights does not take them away from anyone else. There is not a limited number of rights, or slices, to go around.
β€οΈππ€