Mysterical Players

Home
United States
Milford, NJ
Mysterical Players

Mysterical Players is an innovated murder mystery troupe specializing in both fun pre-written comedy

MURDER MYSTERY DINNER THEATER GROUP
Serving the Northern NJ/ & NJ Areas.

03/12/2026

The Mysterical Players newest Show:

Murder mystery dinner show. ClassASSiNATE Reunion with a full 5 course sit down dinner a complimentary glass of wine or soda with dinner and show all for $65.00 per person. BYOB.. Only 50 tickets available. DeMarcos Rest. Tickets available at www.mystericalplayers.com. Questions call: 973-617-6199. March 27th. 8pm show. Doors open 7:30pm

02/18/2026

Our newest show. Come see ClassASSiNATE Reunion with a full 5 course sit down dinner a complimentary glass of wine or soda with dinner and show all for $65.00 per person. BYOB if you would like. Only 50 tickets available. Tickets available at www.mystericalplayers.com. Questions call: 973-617-6199.

11/02/2025

Some pictures from our most recent show SCARE RETREAT. See you at our next show!!

10/06/2025

Halloween Murder Mystery Dinner and Show at Silvio's Villa in Warwick NY. Dinner & Show $58.00. www.Mystericalplayers.com Full Buffet Dinner with Dessert & Coffee, Restaurant Tax & Gratuity Included.
Relatives of some of the most famous Horror Films ever have been brought together for a Retreat. Why and Who has a Vendetta against them? Why were all of them summoned to this location and what is in Store for them? Join Freddy, Jason, Damion, Elvira, Michelle, and Annabelle for an evening of Murder, Mayhem and Suspense.
Plenty of Clues, Plenty of Mystery, Plenty of Jumps, and PLENTY OF SUSPENSE. Guess The Murder and the Motive for a chance to win a prize.
Tickets at Mystericalplayers.com. See Flyer For more Details.

07/05/2025

The Mysterical Players present: MURDER ON THE MENU
Friday July 11th, 2025. Doors open 6:30pm. Show 7pm.
Silvios Villa, Warwick NY
$58.00 (plus 50 cent processing fee) for Full Buffet Dinner, Dessert, Coffee or Tea. Restaurant Gratuity & Tax included. Cash Bar available. Show included. Solve the crime for a chance to win a prize!!
Tickets at: www.mystericalplayers.com

"Join Phil Laye at the grand opening of his new restaurant, Laye’s Seafood. Phil has hired the well-known chef Marla Stewitt, she will unveil the menu of her secret family recipe.
Attending this event will be Marla’s daughter, Callie Marrey, who’s going through a bit of a rough patch right now, Phil’s entertainer nephew, Clem Ciaodor, and the well-known food critic, Freda Mills, who has never given Phil a good review. Come feast on the scrumptious combination of hysterical mayhem, food, entertainment, and an appetizer of murder to whet your palate."🕵️‍♂️

06/12/2025

The Mysterical Players Present: Murder on The Menu. Friday July 11th 7pm. Doors open at 6:30pm at Silvio's Italian Villa, Warwick, NY. $58.00 per person gets you full buffet dinner, show, tax, and restaurant gratuity. Cash bar available. Reservations required. Advanced ticket Sales only.

Tickets purchased at:
https://mystericalplayers.com/index.html :

03/22/2025

Send a message to learn more

Address

West Milford
Milford, NJ
07480

Telephone

+19735069386

Website

http://www.mystericalplayers.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mysterical Players posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Establishment

Send a message to Mysterical Players:

Shortcuts

Want your establishment to be the top-listed Arts & Entertainment in Milford?