06/03/2026
Some legends don't know how to let go. And sometimes, that's the most revealing thing about them.
Ben Roethlisberger stepped away from football in January 2022 after eighteen years, two Super Bowl rings, and a franchise record that may never be touched. He earned every bit of reverence Pittsburgh gave him. But reverence, it turns out, can curdle into something else — something smaller — when the man who built the standard can't stop measuring everyone against it.
The latest episode involves Drew Allar, the Steelers' third-round pick out of Penn State, and a moment so ordinary it almost defies commentary. Allar was working on three-step drops. Basic footwork. The kind of foundational drill every quarterback — including Roethlisberger himself, once upon a time — had to grind through at some point. Big Ben watched that footage and told listeners of his Footbahlin podcast he was "incredibly nervous."
Pittsburgh sports radio host Mark Madden heard that and didn't let it slide.
"Ben is awfully petty," Madden said plainly on 105.9's The X. And he backed it up: Roethlisberger went 13-0 as a starter in the regular season as a rookie, thrust into the lineup in Week 3 after Tommy Maddox went down with an injury. The Steelers drafted him 11th overall at the personal insistence of owner Dan Rooney. Bill Cowher called him a franchise quarterback before he'd thrown a meaningful NFL pass. He wasn't developed. He arrived.
That's not a blueprint. That's a thunderstorm.
Drew Allar is not a thunderstorm — not yet. He's a 76th overall pick with a 6-foot-5 frame, a 24-touchdown season at Penn State in 2024, and a 2025 regression followed by a season-ending injury that sent him sliding down draft boards. Every analyst noted the footwork. Everyone knew the project. That's the entire point of why Pittsburgh took him where they did.
The Steelers aren't asking Allar to win in Week 3. They're asking him to unlearn bad habits and rebuild from the foundation up. A three-step drop being shaky right now isn't alarming. It's the diagnosis before the treatment.
What is alarming — at least to Madden — is a pattern.
When Mason Rudolph was drafted in 2018, Roethlisberger told a Pittsburgh radio station he was surprised the team picked someone who couldn't "help this team now" and quietly sidestepped the question of mentoring him. Years later, Big Ben acknowledged there was maybe one quarterback on the Steelers roster who felt he'd never been good to them. He left the name unsaid. Everyone understood anyway.
He wasn't like that about Will Howard, the sixth-round pick who entered this offseason with zero regular-season NFL snaps. Roethlisberger praised Howard warmly — called him "Pittsburgh," said he could develop into a top-ten quarterback, said he had the kind of heart and fire that fits the franchise. High praise, generously offered, for a player with a far thinner resume than Allar.
Madden connected the dots in the most direct way possible: "I think Ben doesn't want a quarterback to be any good for the Steelers ever again."
That's a sharp accusation. Maybe unfair. Maybe not.
What can't be disputed is this: Roethlisberger's lens was built by an experience almost no quarterback in NFL history has ever shared. He didn't grow. He erupted. And every quarterback who has walked into that building since — Trubisky, Pickett, Rudolph, Wilson, Fields — has been quietly held to a standard that had nothing to do with development and everything to do with immediate, almost supernatural readiness.
Aaron Rodgers is the starter. Allar has a full year to breathe, rebuild, and learn. Rodgers has already said he's willing to help Allar and Howard as much as they want. That runway didn't exist for Ben, and it's hard to know if he resents others having it or simply doesn't understand it.
Either way, Drew Allar is doing the work quietly. Three-step drops. The basics. The beginning.
The best thing he can do is make the criticism irrelevant.